A decade following the UK stumbled into a hasty referendum that polarised the country and triggered disorder, a warning is issued from across the Irish Sea: it may occur once more.
The government and electorate drifted into Brexit and the same might transpire with a referendum on a united Ireland, sparking disturbances for which nobody is prepared.
That represents the warning from two respected commentators from both sides of the Irish border who have joined forces to examine the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to form a different country with the Republic of Ireland.
Political Institutions Unprepared
The author and columnist and Sam McBride, have determined that the political establishments in Ireland and Britain are extremely unready for a possibly contentious and transformative public vote.
"The lesson of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that developments can come out of the blue and can gather momentum rapidly," O’Toole said. "It is my view that the institutional structure of our region remains extremely volatile."
Released Volume Intends to Provoke Discussion
The duo have examined the political, economic and societal reasons for any governmental shift in a volume, The Case For and Against Unification, released by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.
They hope to encourage dialogue on the topic with a tour of lectures that will lead them to Westminster in the coming weeks.
"What haunts everybody, or should haunt all involved, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," commented O’Toole.
"We must avoid a national vote on a binary, ambiguous question whose results have remained undefined because then you land with an extraordinarily divided society where the losing side are resistant to losing and the people who have won are uncertain precisely what it is that they have gained."
Governmental Mandate
Under the Good Friday agreement, the Northern Ireland government minister must arrange a referendum on Irish unification if it seems probable that a most voters would approve.
Nationalist parties and other pro-unification groups claim this point is approaching, and a group named pro-unification advocates has rallied support, but both governments and unionists minimise the prospect, resulting in ambiguity if and when there will be a national vote.
Lack of Substantive Discussion
Ideological statements supporting and opposing unification has obscured the absence of informed dialogue, noted McBride.
"People tend to be for or against the concept but the actual thinking which could extend past that to realise it has largely not occurred. Much has taken place in universities but hardly any politicians or campaigners seek to involve themselves with the basics. For instance, which kind of country might be preferred? Centralised? Federal?"
Book's Approach
In the volume, no writer supports unity or the status quo. They writes two articles that strive for objectivity in detailing the argument for a unified Ireland and the case against, marshalling economic and social data, past examples and constitutional models.
Debates range over identity markers, duties, medical care, elderly benefits, public liabilities and the risk of pro-UK militancy. The aim is to educate and stimulate dialogue.
"Considerable attention exists in the subject but there hasn't quite been a dialogue," stated O’Toole. "Debate suggests an recognition of the concept that there might be reasonable perspectives on both sides."
Simultaneous Plebiscites
A public vote in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where citizens report they prefer unity but refuse increased taxation or implementing a alternative symbol to acknowledge pro-UK communities' UK heritage.
"The Irish government should establish what the plan from pro-unification movements is other than just stating: 'We desire a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," stated the commentator.
Possibility of Public Vote
McBride believes a referendum in his lifetime is possible and that it might occur suddenly. "There might be just a irresponsible or a ill-advised or a feckless official who declares: 'Let us proceed and resolve it.'"
Both pro-unification advocates and pro-UK supporters have credible, justified arguments, he said. "One side will succeed on this issue and the other side will in the end lose but all factions has has valuable insights to gain from the opposing arguments."
Request for Broader Debate
Westminster needed to engage with the debate, said O’Toole. "This involves Britain. It's a UK matter just as much as it is an Irish matter."